CO129-228 - Acting Governor Marsh - 1886 [7-9] — Page 349

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

Firm, Regiment, Ship, or Master to

Enclosure 4

Acting Colonial Secretary.

Mintre

by

the Acting Attorney General.

(Copy)

who probably controls the distribution.

I think it would be very advisable to have control on the trade and storage of arms. During the riots in October 1884 I considered the gem shops in the vicinity of the disturbance, a source of great danger to the peace of the City, and for a time the arms were removed.

Sgd. J. C. Campbell, Ullajos Act'g Capt. Supt. of Police

13th August, 1886.

I have no objection to what is called Class Legislation, when the necessity for it has been clearly established; but, in the case of the proposed Arms Bill, I do not think the words "Chinese, Malay, or Indian" should be struck out, and the word "person" used instead, in Sections 3 and 11.

The "Chinese, Malays, and Indians are not the only persons who give trouble to the Authorities by the carrying of arms. Sailors of various nationalities have occasion to be on shore in Hongkong and made use of deadly weapons. But, apart from this, I am of opinion that the words "without reasonable excuse" in the 3rd Section render it possible to apply the law to the whole community without distinction of race, and at the same time prevent any person's liberty from being unnecessarily interfered with. Every person ought

Edit History

2026-05-25 05:48:02 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
Firm, Regiment, Ship, or Master to Enclosure 4 Acting Colonial Secretary. Mintre by the Acting Attorney General. (Copy) who probably controls the distribution. I think it would be very advisable to have control on the trade and storage of arms. During the riots in October 1884 I considered the gem shops in the vicinity of the disturbance, a source of great danger to the peace of the City, and for a time the arms were removed. Sgd. J. C. Campbell, Ullajos Act'g Capt. Supt. of Police 13th August, 1886. I have no objection to what is called Class Legislation, when the necessity for it has been clearly established; but, in the case of the proposed Arms Bill, I do not think the words "Chinese, Malay, or Indian" should be struck out, and the word "person" used instead, in Sections 3 and 11. The "Chinese, Malays, and Indians are not the only persons who give trouble to the Authorities by the carrying of arms. Sailors of various nationalities have occasion to be on shore in Hongkong and made use of deadly weapons. But, apart from this, I am of opinion that the words "without reasonable excuse" in the 3rd Section render it possible to apply the law to the whole community without distinction of race, and at the same time prevent any person's liberty from being unnecessarily interfered with. Every person ought
Baseline (Original)
Firne, Regiment, Ship, or Master to Enclosure 4 Acting Colonial Secretary. Miente by the A ARE TAO. o expervision over (Copy) who probably the distribution. I think it would be very advisable to have control on the trade and storage of arms. During the rich in October 1884 I considered the gem shops in the vicinity of the disturbance, source. a_ of great deenger to the peace Cety, and of the City, for a time. the aru re rencoved ario were/ Sof I. C. Cempeter, Ullajos Act 9 Capt." Sup! of Police 13th August, 1886. I have no 347 objection to what is ___ called Class Legislation, when the necessity for the care it has been clearly established; but, in of the proposed Arme Bill, I u well think the words "Chiure, Malay, or Indian should be struck out, and the word person used instead, in Sections 3 and 11. The "Chinese, Malays, and Indians are not the only persons who give trouble to the Authorities by the carrying of arms. Sailors of ve many ttee on a free of various nationalities have occasions in Hougkong made of deadly weapons But, apart from this, Jam of on- shore. opinion that the words "without reasonable excuse " in the 3rd Section reuder it " m race, possible to apply the law to the whole community without dictivation of re and at the sauce time prevent any person's liberty from being unnecessarily interfered with. Every pewon ought to
2026-05-25 05:48:02 · Baseline
View content

Firne, Regiment, Ship, or Master to

Enclosure 4

Acting Colonial Secretary.

Miente

by

the A

ARE TAO.

o expervision over

(Copy)

who probably the distribution.

I think it would be

very advisable to have control on the trade and storage

of arms. During the rich in October 1884 I considered the gem shops in

the vicinity of the disturbance,

source.

a_

of great deenger to the peace Cety, and

of the City, for a time.

the aru

re rencoved

ario were/

Sof I. C. Cempeter, Ullajos Act 9 Capt." Sup! of Police

13th August, 1886.

I have no

347

objection to what is ___

called Class Legislation, when the necessity for

the

care

it has been clearly established; but, in of the proposed Arme Bill, I u well think the words "Chiure, Malay, or Indian

should be struck out, and the word

person used instead, in Sections 3 and 11.

The "Chinese, Malays, and Indians are not the only persons who give trouble to the Authorities by the carrying of arms. Sailors of ve

many

ttee

on

a free

of various nationalities have occasions in Hougkong made of deadly weapons But, apart from this, Jam of

on-

shore.

opinion that the words "without reasonable excuse " in the 3rd Section reuder it

"

m

race,

possible to apply the law to the whole community without dictivation of re and at the sauce time prevent any person's liberty from being unnecessarily interfered with. Every pewon ought

to

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.